Woody Oriental · updated 2026-06-15
We merged every alternative to Apple Brandy + By The Fireplace across DTC houses (ALT, Dua, Oakcha), community clone lists and clonespreadsheet's verified similarity ratings — then scored each by how many independent sources agree and how close they measure. Ranked best-match first.
Ranked by consensus
Some links below are affiliate links — if you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are accurate as of the time shown and may change.
Dupe of Apple Brandy + By The Fireplace
Dua Pomme Fire is a woody oriental alternative targeting the apple-and-fireplace warmth of the originals, scoring 68/100 similarity; Dua is a known clone house, so projection and longevity may fall slightly short of the By Kilian/MMM originals at a fraction of the price.
“Budget apple-fire clone, decent overlap”
Dupe of Apple Brandy + By The Fireplace
Dupe of Apple Brandy + By The Fireplace
Dua Apple Cognac's name directly references the apple-and-brandy character of the source fragrances, giving it a plausible conceptual match at 68/100, though as a Dua release the longevity and depth of the woody oriental base may be lighter than the designer originals.
“Name-aligned pick, lighter depth likely”
We have not personally tested these — every score blends independent community and reviewer sources, weighted by independence, with no paid placement. Read the full methodology →
No paid placements — just the trade-offs
All three alternatives cluster at 68/100, chasing the cozy apple-and-fireplace warmth of the By Kilian/MMM originals at a fraction of designer cost, but they get there along slightly different paths.
Edges to the top because its woody oriental build directly targets both halves of the brief — the crisp apple and the smoky fireplace warmth — making it the most conceptually complete match here; as a Dua clone, expect projection and longevity to run a touch shorter than the originals.
Ties on similarity and nails the apple-and-brandy facet by name, but the note flags a lighter, less developed woody oriental base, so the fireplace depth likely reads thinner than Pomme Fire's — strong on concept, slightly softer on the smoky backbone.
Lands at the same 68/100 but ranks last because we have no supporting note on its notes, base or performance — the score stands, yet there's less here to verify the apple-fire character against, so it's the most speculative of the three.
Bottom line: Go with Dua Pomme Fire for the fullest apple-plus-fireplace impression for the money; pick Apple Cognac if the brandy/cognac facet matters most and you'll accept a lighter base, and treat Wasted Moment as the wildcard until you can sample it.
Apple Brandy + By The Fireplace is a collaborative fragrance born from two iconic houses — By Kilian and Maison Martin Margiela — blending Kilian Hennessy's signature gourmand-oriental richness with Margiela's beloved "By The Fireplace" concept of smoky, warming comfort. The result is a Woody Oriental that evokes the sensory experience of sipping apple brandy beside a crackling fire: warm, boozy apple notes layered over smoky, woody, and sweet accords. Its cozy, luxurious, and universally appealing character — combined with its limited-edition prestige positioning — makes it one of the most sought-after dupes targets in the niche fragrance world.
When shopping for a dupe of Apple Brandy + By The Fireplace, the key qualities to prioritize are the balance between fruity boozy sweetness (the apple brandy facet) and the smoky, woody warmth (the fireplace facet) — clones that lean too far in either direction will miss the magic of the original. Longevity and projection matter here, as the original is known for its enveloping, long-lasting sillage, so check community reviews on how well each alternative performs on skin and fabric. At the budget tier, Dua Pomme Fire ($65.00, 68/100 match) and Alexandria Wasted Moment ($69.99, 68/100 match) are the closest verified options our data identifies, with all three alternatives scoring equally at 68/100 — meaning none is a slam-dunk clone, but all capture meaningful elements of the profile. Because the original's retail price is at the premium niche level, even the closest dupes represent a significant saving, making them worth sampling before committing. If budget is the primary concern, Dua Pomme Fire is the cheapest confirmed option at $65.
People also ask
Apple Brandy + By The Fireplace is a Woody Oriental fragrance that combines the warmth of smoky, fireside accords from Maison Martin Margiela's By The Fireplace DNA with the boozy, sweet apple-and-brandy richness of By Kilian's gourmand sensibility. The overall effect is cozy, sweet-smoky, and warming — like a fireside moment with a glass of apple brandy in hand.
Based on our data, the top-scoring dupes are Dua Pomme Fire, Alexandria Wasted Moment, and Dua Apple Cognac — all scoring 68 out of 100. Dua Pomme Fire ($65.00) and Alexandria Wasted Moment ($69.99) are both available for purchase, while Dua Apple Cognac pricing is currently unavailable. None of these are exact clones, but all capture key elements of the original's apple, boozy, and smoky-woody character.
The cheapest confirmed alternative in our dataset is Dua Pomme Fire at $65.00. Since Apple Brandy + By The Fireplace is a limited-edition collaborative release from two prestige niche houses, it typically commands a significant premium — meaning a $65 dupe could represent savings of well over $100 depending on current market pricing for the original.
If you prize the prestige, packaging, and the nuanced complexity of a fragrance crafted by two iconic niche houses, the original is a unique collector's item that dupes can only approximate — the top alternatives score 68/100, meaning there is still a meaningful gap. However, if your main goal is to enjoy a warm, smoky, apple-brandy scent profile in daily wear, the available dupes offer a compelling, budget-friendly entry point worth sampling first.