Independent. We don't sell dupes or belong to any brand — we just score them.
DupeLuxe.
Search every dupe

Setting Spray · updated 2026-06-15

The best One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray dupes

We compiled and scored the affordable, currently-available dupes for One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray — ranked by how close they really are, with live prices and direct links.

Ranked by consensus

Every One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray dupe, scored & ranked

Some links below are affiliate links — if you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are accurate as of the time shown and may change.

#1 85/100 NYX Professional Makeup Matte Finish Setting Spray

Dupe of One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray

NYX Professional Makeup — Matte Finish Setting Spray

● Very close

Both deliver a strong matte, oil-controlling finish with solid all-day hold, but NYX has a more basic mist and a sharper alcohol scent for a fraction of the price.

“Best budget matte match”

Known dupe widely cited as a One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray dupe
$9.97
Check price at Amazon → Save $1864% less than the One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray Amazon price · checked 2026-07-30 23:00:01 UTC
#2 83/100 NYX Professional Makeup Matte Finish Setting Spray Mini

Dupe of One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray

NYX Professional Makeup — Matte Finish Setting Spray Mini

● Very close

Same matte, oil-controlling formula as the full size in a travel format, giving very similar performance at minimal cost.

“Travel-size budget pick”

Known dupe widely cited as a One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray dupe
$9.97
Check price at Amazon → Save $1864% less than the One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray Amazon price · checked 2026-07-30 23:00:01 UTC
#3 82/100 Urban Decay All Nighter Long-Lasting Setting Spray

Dupe of One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray

Urban Decay — All Nighter Long-Lasting Setting Spray

● Very close

The original long-wear benchmark with comparable sweat- and humidity-proof hold, though it reads slightly more natural/skin-like versus On 'Til Dawn's more distinctly matte finish.

“Premium long-wear gold standard”

Known dupe widely cited as a One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray dupe
$34.00
Check price at Amazon → vs $28 retail Amazon price · checked 2026-07-30 23:00:01 UTC
#4 75/100 Milani Make It Last Setting Spray (Matte)

Dupe of One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray

Milani — Make It Last Setting Spray (Matte)

● Good enough

Offers a comparable matte, long-wearing finish for oily skin at a lower price point, though hold in extreme heat/sweat is slightly less robust.

“Affordable matte alternative”

Known dupe widely cited as a One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray dupe
$9.99
Check price at Amazon → Save $1864% less than the One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray Amazon price · checked 2026-07-30 23:00:01 UTC
#5 55/100 e.l.f. Power Grip Dewy Setting Spray

Dupe of One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray

e.l.f. — Power Grip Dewy Setting Spray

● Worth a look

A cult-favorite affordable spray with great gripping hold, but its dewy, glowy finish is the opposite of On 'Til Dawn's matte look.

“Cheap hold, wrong finish”

Known dupe widely cited as a One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray dupe
$10.00
Check price at Amazon → Save $1864% less than the One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray Amazon price · checked 2026-07-30 23:00:01 UTC

We have not personally tested these — every score blends independent community and reviewer sources, weighted by independence, with no paid placement. Read the full methodology →

No paid placements — just the trade-offs

Why these rank the way they do

On 'Til Dawn's signature is a distinctly matte, oil-controlling finish with all-day hold, so these alternatives are ranked mostly on how closely they reproduce that matte staying power rather than just generic "setting spray" hold.

NYX Professional Makeup Matte Finish Setting Spray

Lands at the top because it nails the two things that define the original — a strong matte, oil-controlling finish and solid all-day wear — for a fraction of the cost; it loses a few points only for a more basic mist and a sharper alcohol scent.

NYX Professional Makeup Matte Finish Setting Spray Mini

Essentially the same matte, oil-controlling formula in a travel size, so performance is very similar; it ranks a touch below the full size purely on format and value-per-use, not finish.

Urban Decay All Nighter Long-Lasting Setting Spray

The long-wear gold standard with comparable sweat- and humidity-proof hold, but it reads slightly more natural and skin-like rather than truly matte, which is why it sits just behind the NYX matte options for this specific original.

Milani Make It Last Setting Spray (Matte)

A genuine matte, long-wearing option for oily skin at a lower price, but its hold in extreme heat and sweat is slightly less robust, so it scores a step down from the top matte matches.

e.l.f. Power Grip Dewy Setting Spray

Ranks lowest here despite well-loved gripping hold because its dewy, glowy finish is the direct opposite of On 'Til Dawn's matte look — the trade-off is finish, not quality.

Bottom line: Grab the NYX Matte (or its mini for travel) if you want On 'Til Dawn's matte oil control on the cheap; pay a bit more for Urban Decay if you prioritize maximum long-wear over a hard matte, and skip the e.l.f. unless you actually want a dewy glow.

About One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray & its dupes

One Size On 'Til Dawn Mattifying Waterproof Setting Spray is Patrick Starrr's long-wear setting spray formulated to lock makeup in place through heat, humidity, sweat, and tears. It's known for a matte-leaning finish, a strong hold, and a refreshing feel, making it popular among oily-skin users and anyone needing makeup to survive long, hot days. It uses a fine mist application and is marketed as transfer-resistant and budge-proof rather than a dewy, skin-glow type of spray.</parameter> <parameter name="howToChoose">Pick your dupe based on what you value most. If maximum hold and waterproof, sweat-proof staying power is the priority, the Urban Decay All Nighter and NYX Matte Finish are the closest performance matches — All Nighter for a premium feel, NYX for unbeatable value. If you have oily skin and want that matte, mattifying finish, NYX Matte Finish and Milani Make It Last (matte) are the best fits. Note that many "setting spray dupes" actually shift finish (dewy vs. matte), so match the finish first, then hold. For sensitive skin or fragrance concerns, patch test, as several long-wear sprays contain alcohol and fragrance.</parameter> <parameter name="faq">[{"q":"Is the NYX Matte Finish setting spray really a dupe for On 'Til Dawn?","a":"It's the most commonly cited budget dupe because both deliver a matte, long-wearing finish geared toward oily skin. NYX is significantly cheaper and holds well, though many find On 'Til Dawn slightly more comfortable and refined in mist quality."},{"q":"What's the difference between On 'Til Dawn and Urban Decay All Nighter?","a":"All Nighter is the original long-wear benchmark and runs slightly more flexible/skin-like, while On 'Til Dawn leans more distinctly matte and mattifying. Both offer strong all-day, sweat-resistant hold."},{"q":"Will a setting spray make my makeup truly waterproof?","a":"No setting spray makes makeup fully waterproof, but matte long-wear formulas like these meaningfully improve resistance to sweat, humidity, and light water. For full waterproofing you still need waterproof base products underneath."},{"q":"Are these sprays good for dry skin?","a":"Most matte long-wear setting sprays, including On 'Til Dawn and its dupes, can emphasize dry patches. Dry-skin users often prefer a dewy hydrating spray, or should apply a moisturizing primer first."}]

How to choose a One Size On Til Dawn Setting Spray dupe